View Single Post
Old 10-12-25, 00:48   #58
Ladybbird
 
Ladybbird's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2011
Posts: 50,563
Thanks: 28,767
Thanked 14,428 Times in 10,234 Posts
Ladybbird has a reputation beyond reputeLadybbird has a reputation beyond reputeLadybbird has a reputation beyond reputeLadybbird has a reputation beyond reputeLadybbird has a reputation beyond reputeLadybbird has a reputation beyond reputeLadybbird has a reputation beyond reputeLadybbird has a reputation beyond reputeLadybbird has a reputation beyond reputeLadybbird has a reputation beyond reputeLadybbird has a reputation beyond repute

Awards Showcase
Best Admin Best Admin Gold Medal Gold Medal 
Total Awards: 8

Movies Sonia Sotomayor Silences Supreme Court With Blistering Challenge to Trump Lawyer

Sonia Sotomayor Silences Supreme Court Chamber With Blistering Challenge to Trump awyer

An exchange between Justice Sonia Sotomayor and Donald Trumps Solicitor General D. John Sauer briefly silenced the U.S. Supreme Court chamber Tuesday.


MSRAW 10 DEC 2025





Sauer argued in Trump v. Slaughter a case that could redefine the limits of presidential power over independent agencies and give the Trump more authority to fire officials that the Constitution vests full removal authority in the president

AND that a 90 year precedent insulating officials inside those agencies should be discarded showing how far the government intended to take the challenge


You're asking us to destroy the structure of government and to take away from Congress its ability to protect its idea that the government is better structured with some agencies that are independent, Sotomayor said.

Justice Samuel Alito asked Sauer to respond, and he assured the court that overturning the Humphreys Executor precedent allowing Donald Trump to fire independent agency leaders would not fundamentally reshape the government.

The sky will not fall, Sauer said. The entire government will move toward accountability to the people.

The courts liberals appear inclined to believe those removal protections preserve congressional intentions in creating the agencies while the conservative majority appears to view those limits as incompatible with Article II of the Constitution.

What you're saying is the president can do more than the law permits, Sotomayor said.

That silenced the room, and Sauer hurriedly rephrased some of his earlier arguments in favor of reversing Humphrey.

Humphreys must be overruled, Sauer argued. It has become a decaying husk with bold and particularly dangerous pretensions


Sotomayor Rips Trumps Lawyer To His Face
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZdFA_YxG1M
Ladybbird is online now   Reply With Quote